Your painting estimate lists Dunn-Edwards Evershield, a neighbor swears by Sherwin-Williams Duration, and the stucco on your west wall already looks chalky after a few Arizona summers. Both brands sell top-tier exterior paint, so the choice usually comes down to the product line, the data sheet and how the paint goes on in the heat.
Dunn-Edwards and Sherwin-Williams both make professional-grade paint that works on Arizona homes, and neither company's top line is a weak pick. The clearest differences are regional versus national reach, how each brand's data sheets treat hot-weather application, and the color libraries. Dunn-Edwards is a Southwest brand that makes paint at a plant in Phoenix and says its exterior latex paints can go on at temperatures up to 120°F when its hot-weather precautions are followed. Sherwin-Williams is a national company with thousands of stores, and its Emerald and Duration exterior data sheets say not to paint in direct sun, which Dunn-Edwards' own summer rule says too.
ACP works with Dunn-Edwards and Sherwin-Williams products. Our residential exterior painting crews schedule summer work around surface temperature and keep paint and caulk inside the manufacturer's application temperatures, which means the data sheet for the product on that job sets the limits. The comparisons below come from each company's own product pages, data sheets, bulletins and store lists, opened in November 2026.
Key Takeaways For Choosing Between Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams
- Top Exterior Lines: Dunn-Edwards Evershield against Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior and Duration Exterior. All three are acrylic exterior paints that list application down to 35°F.
- Heat: Dunn-Edwards recommends the industry-standard 50 to 90°F range but says its exterior latex paints can be applied up to 120°F with its hot-weather precautions. Both brands say to stay out of direct sun.
- Volume Solids: the flat sheens of Emerald Exterior (43%), Duration Exterior (42%), Evershield (39.5%) and SuperPaint Exterior (36%) all fall inside the 35% to 45% range Dunn-Edwards gives for top quality latex paint.
- Stores: Dunn-Edwards lists 31 company stores in Arizona. Sherwin-Williams counted 4,853 company-operated stores across the United States, Canada and the Caribbean at the end of 2025, without a state-by-state count.
- Color: Dunn-Edwards' Perfect Palette, with its Then, Now & Forever collection, holds 2,006 colors, and Sherwin-Williams says it has more than 1,700. Both keep online archives of HOA color schemes.
Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams Company History And Arizona Store Count
Dunn-Edwards is the regional brand and Sherwin-Williams is the national one. Dunn-Edwards traces its start to 1925 in Los Angeles, when two wallpaper salesmen formed the Dunn-Smith Company, which by 1927 had become the Consolidated Wallpaper Corporation of Los Angeles. Today it runs a LEED Gold certified paint plant in Phoenix built with capacity for 30 million gallons a year, and the Evershield data sheet carries a Phoenix address. Dunn-Edwards says its paints are formulated for the climate of the Southwest, from the deserts of Arizona, Nevada and New Mexico to the California coast.
Sherwin-Williams is older and a lot bigger. It traces its start to 1866, when Henry Sherwin went into the paint supply business in Cleveland, and Edward Williams joined him in 1870. It's headquartered in Cleveland, Ohio, and its 2025 annual report on Form 10-K counts 4,853 company-operated paint stores in the United States, Canada and the Caribbean at December 31, 2025.
For an Arizona homeowner, the store count that matters is the one near the house, because a nearby store makes touch-up paint and a paint color match easier to get. The full list of Dunn-Edwards locations shows 31 company stores in Arizona, most of them in the Valley: six in Phoenix, three in Mesa, two each in Chandler, Scottsdale and Peoria, and single stores in Gilbert, Queen Creek, Tempe, Goodyear, Buckeye, Surprise, Anthem and Cave Creek. The rest are in Tucson, Oro Valley, Prescott and Prescott Valley. In Chandler, for instance, there's one on West Chandler Boulevard and one on West Ocotillo Road. Gilbert's store is on East Ray Road. Sherwin-Williams' annual report doesn't break its store count out by state, so we can't give you a matching Arizona number from that source.
"Our crew of Peter, Riley and Elijah were meticulous. Thanks to Rob for meeting us at Sherwin Williams to match paint."
Deborah Holzwarth, Google review of ACP Painting Scottsdale, February 2025
More customer reviews from Valley homeowners are on our testimonials page.
Is Dunn-Edwards Paint Made In Arizona?
Dunn-Edwards does make paint in Arizona, at its LEED Gold certified Phoenix plant, built to produce up to 30 million gallons a year, and its Evershield data sheet lists a Phoenix address. The company isn't Arizona-founded, though. It started in Los Angeles in 1925 as the Dunn-Smith Company, and it now sells through stores across the Southwest, 31 of them in Arizona.
How Dunn-Edwards Evershield Compares With Sherwin-Williams Emerald And Duration Exterior Paint
The like-for-like match for Evershield exterior paint is Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior or Duration Exterior, because those are the lines each company describes in its top terms. Dunn-Edwards exterior paint comes in two acrylic lines on this list, and Sherwin-Williams exterior paint in three. Sherwin-Williams puts two lines at the top of its own ladder, and Dunn-Edwards puts one there.
Dunn-Edwards Exterior Lines:
- Evershield: Dunn-Edwards calls it an ultra premium, ultra-low VOC, 100% acrylic line that provides "maximum protection against UV color fade, mildew, efflorescence, water intrusion, and film failure." It comes in flat through gloss and goes on properly prepared and primed stucco, block, masonry, wood and exterior metal.
- Spartashield: a premium, ultra-low VOC, 100% acrylic exterior line that Dunn-Edwards says provides "exceptional hide, durability and versatility." Dunn-Edwards uses "premium" here and "ultra premium" for Evershield.
Sherwin-Williams Exterior Lines:
- Emerald Exterior: the data sheet calls it Sherwin-Williams' "Best-In-Class" exterior house paint, built on a patented cross-linking 100% acrylic technology, self-priming at two coats for new work and one for repaints, and resistant to blistering, peeling and dirt pickup.
- Duration Exterior: Duration uses Sherwin-Williams' PermaLast technology, and its data sheet calls it "the most durable and longest lasting coating available for protecting the outside of your home." It's self-priming too, with one coat for repaints.
- SuperPaint Exterior: formulated with Sherwin-Williams' Advanced Resin Technology for adhesion, hide and color retention, with a dirt-resistant and mildew-resistant coating.
Sherwin-Williams' two top claims sit side by side, Emerald as "Best-In-Class" and Duration as the most durable, and the company doesn't rank one over the other on those sheets. So a quote that offers Emerald and another that offers Duration are both quoting the top of the Sherwin-Williams line.
Our concrete block wall guide notes that ACP's crews are "manufacturer-trained on the systems built for this climate, including Dunn-Edwards Evershield and Sherwin-Williams Loxon." If you're still deciding between paint types rather than brands, our comparison of acrylic, elastomeric and ceramic exterior paint for Phoenix sun covers that choice.
Volume Solids On The Exterior Data Sheets
Volume solids is a number both brands print that lets you compare their paints on the same scale. Dunn-Edwards' technical bulletin calls it an objective indicator of performance, because it shows how much resin and pigment (the part that stays on the wall) is in the formula. It puts top quality latex paint between 35% and 45% volume solids, and economy paint below 30%.
The flat sheen of each exterior line lists these volume solids, each at plus or minus 2%:
- Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior Flat: 43%
- Sherwin-Williams Duration Exterior Flat: 42%
- Dunn-Edwards Evershield Flat: 39.5%
- Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint Exterior Flat: 36%
All four land inside Dunn-Edwards' own top-quality range. That comparison covers one sheen of each line, the plus or minus 2% tolerance means Emerald and Duration overlap, and the 35% to 45% guide comes from Dunn-Edwards, not an independent lab. Coverage per gallon isn't on this list, since the two companies quote it at different film thicknesses.
Is Dunn-Edwards Evershield Better Than Sherwin-Williams Duration?
Neither data sheet settles it. Both are top-of-line acrylic exterior paints that go on down to 35°F. Duration's flat lists 42% volume solids and Evershield's flat lists 39.5%, each plus or minus 2%, while Dunn-Edwards says its exterior latex paints can be applied up to 120°F with its hot-weather precautions. Pick by availability, color and how the job will be scheduled.
Hot Weather Application Limits On Each Brand's Data Sheets
On paper, Dunn-Edwards gives itself more room on application temperature in the heat. Its hot weather painting bulletin says it's industry standard to apply latex paint at surface temperatures between 50 and 90°F, defines hot weather as above 90 and up to 120°F, and says that while it recommends the standard range, its exterior latex paints can be applied in that hotter range when its hot-weather precautions are followed. The Evershield data sheet repeats the 120°F figure.
Sherwin-Williams is stricter in writing. The Emerald Exterior and Duration data sheets both say "Do not paint in direct sun" and warn that above 80°F the paint sets up quickly. Its homeowner exterior how-to says to avoid painting when temperatures are below 50°F or above 90°F. Phoenix runs past that ceiling often. The National Weather Service counts an average of 111 days a year at or above 100°F in Phoenix for 1991 to 2020, and 21 at or above 110°F.
But the two brands agree on the shade. Dunn-Edwards' summer rule is not to paint in the sun but to follow the shade around the building, painting south-facing walls in the morning before the full heat of the day. It also lists what happens when that's ignored: paint that dries too fast can mud-crack, airless spraying in dry warm weather can leave a grainy dry-spray finish, and a hot surface leaves brush, roller and lap marks.
Both companies also go colder than most people expect. Evershield, Emerald Exterior, Duration and SuperPaint Exterior all list application down to 35°F, with conditions on dew point and overnight lows.
Dunn-Edwards also says to protect Evershield from temperatures above 110°F for extended periods, because extreme temperatures may make the paint unusable.
Can You Paint A House Exterior During An Arizona Summer?
Yes, within the paint maker's limits and usually early in the day. Dunn-Edwards says its exterior latex paints can go on up to 120°F with its hot-weather precautions, and both brands say to keep wet paint out of direct sun. ACP crews often start between 5 and 6 a.m. in summer to finish before the worst afternoon heat.
UV Fade And Dark Colors On Arizona Stucco
Both brands make fade resistance a headline claim. Evershield's data sheet promises "maximum protection against UV color fade," and Sherwin-Williams lists fade resistance for Emerald Exterior. Neither product page nor data sheet says how many years a color lasts in Arizona sun.
What Dunn-Edwards does publish is the mechanism. Its bulletin on dark exterior colors says darker colors absorb more heat and energy than light ones, which can speed up breakdown of the binder, and that a color with a light reflectance value (LRV) closer to 100 reflects more light and stays cooler in the sun. Blistering can be more common in dark colors in direct sun. Dunn-Edwards also shows on exposure panels in Phoenix and Los Angeles that a south-facing wall gets more UV than a north-facing one and weathers first.
So on a south-facing wall, color choice probably matters as much as the brand. Our guide to front door paint and colors for the Arizona sun lists Sherwin-Williams LRVs from black to white if you want to see where a color lands.
Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams Interior Paint Lines Compared
Indoors, Dunn-Edwards splits its lines into ultra-premium and premium, and Sherwin-Williams adds a line aimed at high-traffic rooms.
Dunn-Edwards Interior Lines:
- Suprema: ultra-premium, ultra-low VOC acrylic that Dunn-Edwards says combines "superior applied hide, durability, and block resistance."
- Everest: ultra-premium, Zero VOC, low odor, self-priming 100% acrylic made for "the most lived-in spaces," with what Dunn-Edwards calls exceptional burnish resistance.
- Spartawall: premium, Zero VOC and ultra-low VOC interior acrylic formulated for "a tough, durable, block resistant finish."
Sherwin-Williams Interior Lines:
- Emerald Interior: paint and primer in one with stain-blocking technology, anti-microbial agents that inhibit mold and mildew on the paint surface, and what Sherwin-Williams calls "Exceptional scrub, stain, block, water spotting and burnish resistance." Flat, matte, satin and semi-gloss.
- Duration Home: a paint and primer in one that Sherwin-Williams pitches for high-traffic rooms, with moisture-resistant technology for spaces like bathrooms.
- SuperPaint Interior: paint and primer in one that Sherwin-Williams says holds up to scrubbing, in flat, satin, velvet and semi-gloss.
One difference in how the two companies write about mold is worth knowing. Sherwin-Williams' anti-microbial claim covers the paint surface, while Dunn-Edwards states that its paint can neither cause nor prevent or cure mold or mildew, and that excess moisture and poor ventilation are the main causes. Fix the moisture first, whichever can you open.
Sheen changes how any of these lines looks and cleans, and our paint sheen guide for Arizona homes goes room by room. For the work itself, see our residential interior painting page.
Do You Need Primer Under A Paint And Primer In One?
Sometimes. Emerald Interior and SuperPaint Interior are sold as paint and primer in one, and Everest is self-priming, but Dunn-Edwards says new drywall is very porous and soaks up paint unless it's primed first. Sherwin-Williams' Emerald Interior Latex Matte data sheet says a coat of primer improves the topcoat's hiding on a drastic color change. Bare surfaces and big color jumps still get primer.
Aristoshield And Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel For Doors, Trim And Cabinets
For doors, trim and cabinets, the match-up is Dunn-Edwards Aristoshield against Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel. Both are water-based urethane alkyd enamels built to give an oil-like finish from a water-based formula. Dunn-Edwards lists Aristoshield for doors, trim and cabinets and for metal such as wrought iron, garage doors, handrails and metal doors. Sherwin-Williams limits Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel's exterior use to doors, trim and other small areas of wood or metal, and says not to use it on the main body of a house.
Our July 2026 post on why white cabinets and trim yellow in Arizona homes names Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel and ProClassic Waterbased Acrylic-Alkyd as non-yellowing enamels, and for white cabinet painting ACP sprays "a cabinet-grade enamel made to resist yellowing."
Color Libraries And HOA Color Archives From Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams
Dunn-Edwards paint colors come from a 2,006-color library, Sherwin-Williams says it offers more than 1,700 colors, and both brands keep HOA schemes online. The Dunn-Edwards Perfect Palette holds 2,006 colors: 1,400 core colors, 10 high whites, 100 whites, 100 classics, 96 accents and the 300-color Then, Now & Forever collection. Of those 300, Dunn-Edwards says 142 were inspired by the architecture of the American West and verified as historically accurate by an architecture firm focused on historic preservation.
In an HOA community, the approved scheme can settle the brand question. Sherwin-Williams runs an HOA Color Archive for associations it partners with, and Dunn-Edwards' Color-Ark Pro holds the approved schemes for communities originally painted or repainted with Dunn-Edwards paint. If your community's scheme lives in one of them, the color names and numbers on your application will match that brand's. Our guide to getting your exterior paint job approved by your Arizona HOA covers the paperwork.
ACP's color consultation runs about an hour. On exterior projects it works within HOA rules where they apply, and the consultant can scan the colors of a neighbor's home if you like their scheme.
"She taught us things about walls facing certain directions giving off different hues and the importance of choosing the right tones with that in mind."
Mary Jo Snyder, Google review of ACP Painting Scottsdale, February 2025
How To Choose Between Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams For Your Home
Choose the product line first and the brand second. Going by the data sheets, Sherwin-Williams' own exterior lines sit seven points apart on volume solids (SuperPaint at 36%, Emerald at 43%), while the two companies' top lines sit three and a half points apart (Evershield at 39.5%). So on that measure, an Emerald or Duration quote is probably closer to an Evershield quote than to a SuperPaint quote.
Dunn-Edwards Is Usually The Easier Pick When:
- Your HOA's approved scheme is in Color-Ark Pro, because the community was painted with Dunn-Edwards before.
- The schedule pushes exterior work into hot months, since Dunn-Edwards publishes a 120°F upper limit and the hot-weather steps that go with it.
- You want one of the historic Southwest colors from the Then, Now & Forever collection.
Sherwin-Williams Is Usually The Easier Pick When:
- Your HOA is listed in the Sherwin-Williams HOA Color Archive, or the color you've fallen for is a Sherwin-Williams color.
- You want a self-priming exterior line rated for one coat on repaints, which Sherwin-Williams lists for both Emerald Exterior and Duration.
- You're painting vinyl, since Sherwin-Williams offers 100 VinylSafe colors, including a limited set of darker colors, formulated to resist warping or buckling on sound vinyl.
Whichever logo is on the can, Dunn-Edwards says itself that a premium coating applied incorrectly won't perform to its potential, and that the substrate, the primer, the number of coats and the film thickness all shape how long it lasts.
Resources For Comparing Dunn-Edwards And Sherwin-Williams Paint
- Dunn-Edwards Evershield Flat Product Data Sheet (PDF). The volume solids, temperature limits and primer pairings for Evershield's flat sheen.
- Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior Flat Data Sheet. The matching numbers for Emerald, including the direct sun warning and the 35°F low.
- Dunn-Edwards Technical Bulletin: Volume Solids (PDF). How to read the volume solids line on any brand's data sheet, from Dunn-Edwards' point of view.
- Dunn-Edwards Technical Bulletin: Dark Colors For Exterior Applications (PDF). Why dark colors run hotter and blister more in direct sun, with the LRV explanation.
- Sherwin-Williams HOA Color Archive. Look up whether your association's approved colors are on file with Sherwin-Williams.
- Dunn-Edwards Color-Ark Pro. The same lookup for communities painted with Dunn-Edwards.
Talk To ACP Painting About Paint For Your Arizona Home
If you're weighing two quotes with two different brands on them, call our Maricopa office at 480-785-6323 or request an estimate online. Tell us your HOA, which walls take the afternoon sun and whether you already have a color picked, and we can narrow the brand and the product line before anyone opens a can.
About Russ Byers
Russ Byers is President & Co-Owner of ACP Painting. He co-founded the company in 2005 with his brother Rob, and both are U.S. Army veterans. Russ leads ACP's sales consultants and is a regular guest on Rosie on the House, where ACP has been a Certified Partner since 2024. Read Russ's full bio.
ACP Painting, LLC.
20987 N John Wayne Pkwy
Maricopa, AZ 85139
Phone: 480-785-6323
Category: House Painting